• Rewards Room
    • You are here
    Home / Makeup / Eye shadow / Maybelline New York Lemonade Craze Eyeshadow Palette

    Maybelline New York Lemonade Craze Eyeshadow Palette Trial Team

    Reviewers

    Fifty females aged between 18 and 39.

    Product in Trial

    Maybelline New York

    Lemonade Craze Eyeshadow Palette

    Overall star rating during this trial
    4
    SNAPSHOT*:
    92%

    of members found that they were able to create their desired Summery eye look with the palette.

    86%

    of members were satisfied with the breadth of shades in the palette.

    78%

    of members liked the sweet citrus scent of palette.

    70%

    of members would recommend the palette to their friends and family.

    beautyheaven says:

    The Maybelline New York Lemonade Craze Eyeshadow Palette is an eyeshadow palette including 12 highly pigmented warm-toned shades with a sweet citrus scent. The palette features softer hues to highlight, darker shades to amplify and define, and bright bursts of colour to make eyes pop. From citrus to coral punch, each shade is inspired by the flavours of lemonade.

    The majority of testers felt that the Maybelline New York Lemonade Craze Eyeshadow Palette had a great variety of both shimmer and matte shades. Most triallers were impressed by how versatile the shades were and that they could create multiple colour combinations using the eyeshadow palette. They liked the soft, sweet lemonade scent and also enjoyed the sleek packaging. Triallers found the eyeshadow shades long-lasting and like that the majority of the shades were moderately pigmented, buildable and easy to blend.

    *Based on a survey of 50 beautyheaven Trial Team members.

    The products for this Trial Team have been provided by Maybelline New York for the purpose of trial and review. All reviews submitted are the honest, authentic and genuine sentiments of the beautyheaven members participating in this trial.

    Our independent testers say

    shabelle's picture
    shabelle
    Member since
    1/09/2014

    shabelle

    Star Rating:
    5
    “The Maybelline New York Lemonade Craze Eyeshadow Palette is a pretty, well sized and delicious smelling palette. There's a soft, sweet lemonade smell to the palette. There are so many nice shades, which can be worn with a variety of different styles and looks in mind! I particularly liked the matte 'old-fashioned' shade, which is a chocolate brown and 'ice pop', which is a striking pink shade. The shimmer shades such as 'citrus' and 'sugar-coated' were gorgeous as well! I tried various colour combinations with this palette and was never disappointed! The eyeshadow was very easy to apply, and lasted all day without losing any of its colour.”
    shabelle recommends this product
    Read the full review
    Turquoise Nails's picture
    Turquoise Nails
    Member since
    23/10/2011

    Turquoise Nails

    Star Rating:
    4
    “I tried this product as part of the bh Trial Team and I can honestly say it has exceeded all my expectations! This palette is housed in a sturdy plastic case with 12 shades, with 4 of the more basic shades coming in slightly larger pans than the other shades. I loved the variety of shades in this palette, I was able to create neutral, pink toned or orange toned looks and the palette contained a great mix of matte and shimmer shades. Whilst the palette was moderately pigmented I found that the shadows were easy to build up and MOST shades looked great on the eye. However, there were a few shades which lacked pigmentation including the yellow shade. Overall, I was very impressed with this palette. It is the first drugstore palette I have tried in years that I reach for as much as my high end palettes. I love the range of colours and enjoy the sleek packaging of the product.”
    Turquoise Nails recommends this product
    Read the full review
    Rebecca972's picture
    Rebecca972
    Member since
    17/04/2013

    Rebecca972

    Star Rating:
    4
    “When I first saw this eyeshadow palette I was in love. A neutral palette with pops of colour is right up my alley! When I used the palette for the first time I used a transition light brown and a pale shimmer pink on the lid for an everyday look and it came together so well with absolutely no issues blending. The scent of the palette is beautiful and refreshing (just like sweet lemon) although not overwhelming like a lot of scented palettes can be. I also did swatches which were extremely pigmented and that showed also on the eye. The packaging could be better, mine arrived with the base coming unglued to the outer packaging, but apart from that I have no issues! The eyeshadow lasted well into the night having been worn for 16 hours and I can honestly say I could barely tell the difference! This has to be one of my new favourite palettes and I’ve been reaching for it every day.”
    Rebecca972 recommends this product
    Read the full review
    ronpunzle's picture
    ronpunzle
    Member since
    29/10/2007

    ronpunzle

    Star Rating:
    4
    “I normally don't purchase bright eye palettes as I prefer to stick to neutral and safe colours that I can wear with everything day to night. Receiving this palette I was a little nervous wondering how the colours would go with my outfits and style. At first look this palette is neat, cute and has a great range of colours ranging from neutral to bright. The shadows have a light lemon citrus smell which I liked as it was just a hint and not too powerful. The powders applied with a fairly decent amount of pigment that was quite buildable and they blended with ease. I tried out several different looks that lasted through 12+ hour days and even experimented with the yellow, pink and orange. These brighter colours actually worked really well with my medium olive skin tone and didn't clash at all. I particularly liked the orange surprisingly!”
    ronpunzle recommends this product
    Read the full review
    Beautybyjessss's picture
    Beautybyjessss
    Member since
    12/06/2014

    Beautybyjessss

    Star Rating:
    5
    “I absolutely loved trialling this eyeshadow palette! Despite being small in pan sizes, it really packs a punch. I used this for my everyday look as i quite like the natural tones if offered. From the packaging side, it is light and compact and can easily fit into a makeup bag/travel bag. The causing is sturdy and durable. the clear pane window on the front is really helpful to see what shades you have and to easily decide if that's the palette you want to use. the shadows themselves are a mix of matte and shimmer and are super pigmented. Like makeup geek pigmented! I used these shadows when there was a heatwave and the temps were 30+ degrees and they didn't budge. After a long 12+ hour day, the colours were still highly pigmented and in place. There is minimal fallout when applying these shadows. Overall I am really pleased with this palette!”
    Beautybyjessss recommends this product
    Read the full review

    24 Member Comments

    Sootyhere 31 May 2019 1:57 PM
    Bit too bright and not sure why they have scented it. I'm sure many would be happy with this eye palette. Just not for me. I prefer more natural shades
    Petal 22 Mar 2019 1:39 PM
    I had no idea that this eyeshadow palette is scented, but I didn't plan on buying it. I'm looking for an eyeshadow palette with more cool undertones.
    RitaB 24 Feb 2019 3:50 PM
    I see this palette everywhere! Looks like it has mostly positive reviews, so it is living up to the hype!
    Shop A Everyday 20 Feb 2019 9:43 PM
    These are half price! Wow what a bargain!
    Susmat 18 Feb 2019 9:38 AM
    This is a repeat post from not very long ago
    Susmat 17 Feb 2019 10:56 AM
    Interesting that they are scented,
    Sootyhere 31 May 2019 1:58 PM
    Not sure why Susmat
    Shop A Everyday 16 Feb 2019 7:56 PM
    Ooh scented hey? wonder if our noses are sniff upwards towards our eye lids lol
    Tigerlily 16 Feb 2019 2:12 PM
    Surprised not many people would recommend the palette!
    clearcrystalwater 16 Feb 2019 7:53 AM
    I saw this yesterday in Woollies for 1/2 price! "That's why I shop at Woollies" ; ?

    I was checking out the mattes in it - four of them were mattes. The other colours were glittery and some shimmers.
    MoonlightSak16 18 Feb 2019 2:47 PM
    Thanks CCW for the bargain tip. Might need to check my local woolies.
    Sally10 15 Feb 2019 5:49 PM
    A bit bright for me, I think.
    perthchick 15 Feb 2019 2:20 PM
    I’ve seen these at Chemist Warehouse. They look lovely.
    haylee_ 15 Feb 2019 10:46 AM
    The Trial Team results are similar to what I've read and seen people say about it. I love how fun it looks - it's very on trend - but once you've got 10+ eyeshadow palettes I think you become more picky about what you buy. Colours easily start repeating themselves. I too didn't realise it was scented, so this is good to know!
    Rpear 15 Feb 2019 10:41 AM
    I didn't release it would be scented! That could be OK ! Haha well I wonder if this can be enjoyed if you have cool undertones. I like the look of the colours! Kinda surprised the results aren't higher if the colours and looks could be created.
    MoonlightSak16 18 Feb 2019 2:48 PM
    Wow I am curious about the scent too.
    Nicoler112 15 Feb 2019 5:39 PM
    I was on the trial and have cool undertones. I found it quite limiting. I usually wear a lot of bronzes and cooler browns with my blue eyes. I found the yellow and pink bright shades worked and the bright bronze shade, but otherwise definitely one for those who have warm undertones.
    Ethelinde 14 Feb 2019 9:44 PM
    While I think the idea is creative, scented eyeshadows are a no go for me. I try to avoid a lot of things which are scented as it is.
    MoonlightSak16 14 Feb 2019 2:52 PM
    Interesting colours!!
    onlyoni 14 Feb 2019 9:05 AM
    The trial team results aren't too impressive. It's not a palette I would choose to use because of the bright colours, but it looks like a fun palette for those who are interested.

    Pages

    You need to log in or become a member to post a comment.
    Lush
    American Cream Shower Gel
    1 review
    1566264978

    Smells Divine

    5

    This shower gel has a smooth texture to it. It was like baby powder, fairy floss, type of scent very soft and gorgeous. The lather is out of this world you only need the tiniest amount.

    Read More
    Maybelline New York
    Total Temptation Mascara
    70 reviews
    1566264106

    Total Volume

    4

    I love this Mascara. It adds the most beautiful volume to my lashes. It does not flake or smudge or clump on me.

    Read More
    QV Skincare
    QV Intensive Body Moisturiser
    42 reviews
    1566260640

    Fast, gentle relief for extremely dry skin!

    4

    I usually have very oily skin but lately I've had dermatitis on localised areas of my face - mostly my forehead, sides of the nose, ear lobes and below the brow bone.

    Read More
    1. Beautybabe140194
      1566225758
      Where to buy Costume Accessories Perth Melbourne or Sydney

      Hi Ladies, Just wondering where I can buy costume accessories like gloves, showgirl headpiece, and…

      Read More
    2. anayarazeen
      1566210503
      Caboki Hair Building Fiber in Pakistan

      Caboki Hair Building Fiber in Pakistan completely safe solution for men and women. Caboki Hair Building…

      Read More
    3. jamesethan
      1566207950
      Herbal Treatment for Abdominal Adhesions

      Herbal Treatment for Abdominal Adhesions which can helpful for your health without any side effects…

      Read More
    4. bh's Eleni
      1566171241
      beautyheaven Lovekins Member Event

      Hey Beauties, We have a super exciting event for those who are based in Sydney to attend! You…

      Read More
    5. bh's Eleni
      1565930360
      AMAZING August Discovery Bag: APPLICATIONS CLOSED

      Hi beauties! Our AMAZING AUGUST Discovery Bag is here, and we've got some HUGE products for you to…

      Read More
    6. Deeknight
      1565916714
      Natural Beauty

      Hey all!!! Wondering what your favourite natural beauty brands are (skin, hair, makeup etc). Starting…

      Read More
    TOP